These are real stats of two MAC Defensive Linemen.

Year 1:

Player A: 50 Tackles and 4.5 sacks.

Player B: 43 Tackles and 9 sacks

Year 2:

Player A: 33 Tackles and 2.5 sacks

Player B: 39 Tackles and 4.5 sacks

Year 3:

Player A: 77 Tackles and 6.5 sacks

Player B: 56 Tackles and 6 sacks

With 2 players over 3 seasons, you can assign 3 "1st team All-MAC" seasons, 1 "2nd team All-MAC" seasons and 2 "No Award" seasons.

I score mine:

1st Team All-MAC seasons:

Year 1, Player B - 43 Tackles and 9 sacks

Year 3 , Player A - 77 Tackles and 6.5 sacks

and Year 3, Player B - 56 Tackles and 6 sacks

My 2nd team All MAC season would be:

Year 1, Player A: 50 Tackles and 4.5 sacks.

My snubs would be:

both players year 2.

Lets also say, based on these numbers, Player A had 25 tackles and 5 sacks, where would you put him?

For me, it's at least good enough for 3rd team.

Go to the spoilers section of the comments for the reveal.